American Idol has been a go-to show for every music lover out there with its interesting take on music and super famous judges. But what happened in Season 12 of the show truly shocked everyone. In it, pop icons Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey appeared as judges, and what could have been the best season of the franchise turned out to be one of the most contentious.
Mariah Carey | Credits: @mariahcarey/Instagram
Instead of focusing on the participants, Season 12 quickly gained headlines for the alleged feud between Minaj and Carey. The duo reportedly clashed both on and off camera, making it extremely difficult for the show to go on. Let’s dive deeper to understand what actually happened between the two ladies.
How Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj’s feud ruined American Idol Season 12?
When two of the most famous singers get together, that too in a singing show, fans expected great musical magic to take place. However, what happened in Season 12 of American Idol was the complete opposite. The famous panel featured the likes of music legend Mariah Carey, Nicki Minaj, Keith Urban, and industry veteran Randy Jackson.
Nicki Minaj | Credits: @nickiminaj/Instagram
But instead of the competition taking center stage, the real drama took place at the judges table, especially between Carey and Minaj. Their explosive drama turned the singing competition into a spectacle of diva warfare. While things started with subtle jabs, they quickly escalated into full-blown hostility.
Reports as per People surfaced that since the beginning, Carey had been undermining Minaj and even questioned if she qualified to judge the show. While Minaj initially took the digs with stride, one day she just snapped. A leaked behind-the-scenes video showcased her launching into a profanity-laced tirade that shocked everyone present there.
Not just behind the scenes, but their feud was quite evident in front of millions as well. Their onscreen tensions were quite noticeable, as well as their passive-aggressive remarks, making it evident that they were anything but friends. At one point Carey even hired extra security, as reportedly Minaj had made a threatening comment against her.
Related“I didn’t have the kind of money”: Irv Gotti’s Million Dollar Contribution to Nicki Minaj’s Career Will Blow Your Mind
Things also got to a point where rumors started swirling that the producers were even considering firing Minaj to ease up the tension. But nothing of this sort actually happened, and both singers remained on the panel for the entire season.
Why does Nicki Minaj regret recording some of her biggest hits?
Nicki Minaj has built a career on bold lyrics, infectious beats, and a larger-than-life persona, but even she has a few tracks she wishes she could take back. During a candid Q&A session at the Pollstar Live Conference via Yahoo, the rap superstar revealed three songs from her own catalog that she now regrets recording: Anaconda, Your Love, and Starships.
Nicki Minaj | Credits: @nickiminaj/Instagram
While Minaj acknowledged that she still appreciates the music videos for Anaconda and Your Love, she didn’t hold back when critiquing Starships, laughing as she questioned, “Yo, why did I do that?” Despite being one of her biggest commercial hits, the track has long been a point of debate among fans—some praising its crossover appeal, others feeling it leaned too far into pop territory.
Related“Ugly people can do things too”: Ray J, Who Made S*x Tape With Kim Kardashian, Looks Deeply Hurt After Nicki Minaj Calls Him Ugly to His Face
Her honesty about past work isn’t surprising. Minaj has never been one to shy away from speaking her mind, and over the years, she’s evolved both personally and musically. While those three tracks may not be her favorites anymore, they undeniably played a role in shaping her career, helping her break records, dominate charts, and solidify her status as a global superstar.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire