Justin Timberlake was once a budding twelve-year-old on Star Search and then a teen on The All-New Mickey Mouse Club. In 1995, he would take the next step. Convinced by Chris Kirkpatrick’s vision for a boy band, he co-founded *NSYNC with JC Chasez. Joey Fatone and Lance Bass completed the lineup, and the group quickly gained traction with their hit I Want You Back.
By 1997, they had a deal with RCA, and despite *NSYNC’s subsequent success, the group went on hiatus in 2002, setting the stage for Timberlake’s solo career. His debut single, Like I Love You, dropped later that year, leading to his first album, Justified. Packed with hits like Cry Me a River and Rock Your Body, it earned Timberlake two Grammys in 2004.
But decades later, his reputation has faltered. The 2004 Super Bowl incident with Janet Jackson lingers, and Britney Spears’ recent memoir has fueled further backlash. With Everything I Thought It Was released in mid-2024, let’s revisit his discography and take a look at his albums in order of sales.
6. Everything I Thought It Was (2024)
Released on March 15, 2024, Everything I Thought It Was finds Justin Timberlake trying to strike a balance between modern trends and his signature sound. Per ThatGrapeJuice, the album recorded its lowest opening week sales in the U.S., totaling 41,000 (pure copies) and 31.1 million on-demand streams, the album has already sparked conversation for its production.
Everything I Thought It Was | Justin Timberlake, YouTube
The album begins with Memphis, a clear-eyed reflection on his roots, and closes with Conditions, his candid thoughts on fame and its fallout. Between these bookends, Timberlake is nostalgic with an NSYNC reunion on Paradise.
Spanning 76 minutes, tracks like My Favorite Drug and Fuckin’ Up the Disco offer dance-floor energy, while collaborations such as Fireboy DML’s feature on the Afrobeats-inspired Liar and Tobe Nwigwe’s appearance on the gospel-inflected Sanctified reveal the album’s adaptive sound.
Six years after Man of the Woods, Timberlake uses Everything I Thought It Was to reassert some of his age-old pop dominance.
5. Man of the Woods (2018)
Justin Timberlake’s 2018 album Man of the Woods sips on country influences, selling 1.1 million copies and debuting at number one on the Billboard 200. Despite this commercial success, it received mixed reviews. Singles like Filthy and Say Something stood out, but the album suffered from excessive runtime and overindulgence.
Man of the Woods | Justin Timberlake, YouTube
Songs like Midnight Summer Jam stretched simple ideas far beyond their natural lifespan, while tracks such as Supplies and The Hard Stuff feel redundant. The interlude ‘Hers‘ and additional padding further dilute the project.
Thematically, Man of the Woods struggles to balance its promised rustic aesthetic with Timberlake’s pop promises. At over an hour, Man of the Woods is bloated and inconsistent. While it has moments of promise, its inability to deliver a focused narrative makes it a missed opportunity for Timberlake.
4. The 20/20 Experience – 2 of 2 (2013)
Released just six months after The 20/20 Experience, Justin Timberlake’s The 20/20 Experience 2 of 2 aimed to capitalize on the first outing. Selling 1.1 million copies, the album performed solidly but didn’t match the commercial success of its predecessor.
The 20/20 Experience – 2 of 2 | Justin Timberlake, YouTube
Taken from the same recording sessions, 2 of 2 revisits many of the same production techniques: multi-part songs, layered arrangements, and syncopated beats.
Related: What Really Caused Janet Jackson’s Wardrobe Malfunction: Was It Justin Timberlake’s Fault?
Instead of evolving the old-school glamor seen in the first album, it rehashes many of the classic Timberlake tropes, leading to a more stagnant and predictable feel. Tracks like Cabaret and TKO seem to aim for sensuality but end up corny and uncomfortable with awkward, juvenile lyrics.
The album’s attempts at edgier stuff, such as the angst-filled Only When I Walk Away and the hollow Drink You Away, feel forced and fail to resonate. At a bloated 144 minutes across two albums, 2 of 2 leaves its strongest moments lost in a sea of unpolished material.
3. The 20/20 Experience (2013)
The 20/20 Experience was Justin Timberlake’s comeback after a seven-year hiatus, selling an impressive 4.5 million copies. The album presented a more sophisticated sound, with standout tracks like Suit & Tie and Mirrors.
The 20/20 Experience | Justin Timberlake, YouTube
With this album, Timberlake combined retro inspirations – Motown, Stax, and Trojan – with modern production, while incorporating live instrumentation. The album’s themes also revolve around love and admiration, possibly inspired by his 2012 marriage to actress Jessica Biel.
While its expansive, seven-minute tracks risked alienating some listeners, The 20/20 Experience appealed to both longtime fans and new ones, helping make Timberlake a big comeback in his career.
2. FutureSex/LoveSounds (2006)
Selling 8.3 million copies, Justin Timberlake’s FutureSex/LoveSounds, released in 2006, remains his second-best-selling album to date.
FutureSex/LoveSounds | Justin Timberlake, YouTube
Primarily produced by Timbaland, the record traded the R&B-influenced sheen of Justified for a hip-hop-infused sound. It’s full of confidence and an album built on towering self-belief, showing Timberlake as both a consummate lover and hopeless romantic.
Tracks like My Love blur seduction and commitment, while the title track channels Nine Inch Nails’ carnal energy.
The album thrives on its ambition, which melts into the melancholic. Even missteps, like the overwrought Losing My Way, seem fearless. By courting disaster and aiming high, Timberlake created an album that makes a strong case for its willingness to stretch the limits of pop music.
1. Justified (2002)
In 2002, Justin Timberlake made his leap from boy band star to solo artist with Justified. Selling 10 million copies, it became a pivotal moment for Timberlake and has since come to define his career.
Justified | Justin Timberlake, YouTube
While FutureSex/LoveSounds gets credit for reinvention and massive hits like SexyBack, Justified remains Timberlake’s most exciting record. It thrived on its loose vibe, unburdened by the thematic branding that later defined his work. Tracks like the funky Señorita and the obsessive Like I Love You allowed Timberlake to experiment, laugh at his thoughts, and find his voice.
Related: Justin Timberlake and Jimmy Fallon’s On-Screen Chemistry Could Overshadow Even Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman’s Bromance
Co-produced by peak power Timbaland and The Neptunes, Justified was Timberlake’s moment of transition, pushing past *NSYNC’s shadow without losing himself in pretense.
Its grooves, unexpected ad-libs, and fearless energy captured a 21-year-old eager to take over the world, aware of how ridiculous that ambition seemed, and entirely ready to make it happen.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire